Monday, November 15, 2021

What is Productivity

I really resonated with this idea of productivity that Tyler Denmead talks about, both in my personal life and in the work I do working with an arts organization.


I think personally this is something I've always struggled with being someone who has struggled with mental health. A lot of times I am so overwhelmed by tasks or just lack motivation in general that I end up not doing anything (this turns into watching tv or scrolling social media most of the time) and feel guilt for being unproductive. That I'm not doing anything with my life, or I'm not doing the hobbies I enjoy doing because I feel stressed or tired. 

My therapist asked me the other week "but is that not productive to you?" implying that if I've gone to work all day (and sometimes to another job or to class and then working some more on the weekends with some side hustles sprinkled in) is spending my free time as a couch potato unproductive to me. And while I think no because I need that mental break and de-stress of just focussing on if Ross and Rachel were on a break or not (they were NOT if anyone wants my opinion), I think society would look at that and think it's lazy. Maybe that's my idea of how society views things but I think there is just so much pressure to work, and work multiple jobs so you have enough money, socialize with friends, keep up with household chores, contribute to the economy (go shopping, out to dinner, concerts, etc.), cook, sleep 8 hours, have a hobby, be active, the list goes on, that if I use what little free time I have to take a break that I feel shameful. A lot of this is my own anxiety and stress but I don't think I'm the only one who has this tug-of-war with productivity.


I think we do it a lot with our youth too when they express their interest in something. Even when they're young when a child loves to draw we say "oh they're going to be a famous artist one day" or "they're going to be a professional basketball player" because we gave them a basketball toy at 6 months. We're already demonstrated at a young age that we need to monetize and make a career out of the things we enjoy. For some people that's fantastic, I know so many successful artists who enjoy creating and selling their work, but for others, why can't their joy for painting just be a joy for painting? Why do we need to put this pressure on young artists to show their work in galleries and try and get them to monetize on it? A lot of times I think we're then putting stress on people and taking away that joy they once had. I wonder what it would look like to have an art program where youth just come to make art just because they enjoy it. I think New Urban Arts does still do a fantastic job at fostering this and Denmead makes some great points about this pressure coming from potentially harmful adults in those spaces and also how funders and grants are often putting this pressure onto the staff which is projected onto the youth. I wish more people could recognize that sometimes a youth space needs to be just that. Not a space where they can make up work, improve their reading test scores, or get tutoring but a space where youth get to be themselves no questions asked no pressure added. 

2 comments:

  1. Thanks for these reflections Kelly. For me it was a big revelation recently when I realized how much shame I have held around rest and anything really that is not ostensibly productive. That word shame opened something up for me and helped me see the ways that this message is not only broadcast from every corner of American society, but has deep roots in my own history/ family. And of course it is so clear that we (as a society) turn that inward shame (along with additional anxieties and pressures on Black and Brown kids) outward back on to young people.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing, Kelly. I appreciate your honesty around the shame you've felt in being what society and us (internalized capitalism) deem as "unproductive". As someone who also lives with anxiety I FEEL you on that spiral that the the "to-dos" can cause and then the guilt and shame that not being able to do anything causes. It's a cycle I'm trying to get out of too... I aspire to be more "lazy" honestly. Pausing, resting, playing --- those are a few ways we can resist capitalism on a personal level and work towards healing the machines we've made out bodies and minds become. Those are the only ways I've found to connect more with my heart and spirit.

    ReplyDelete

Capstone Project Ideas

The first idea that came to mind was work that I've already been doing with how after-school programs can help disrupt the school-to-pri...